Recently, Elsevier’s Ain Shams Engineering Journal retracted two papers after discovering that the authors used unlicensed software in their research. The papers, which explored dam failures, relied on FLOW-3D, a computational fluid dynamics application developed by Flow Science. The software’s creators filed a complaint after an editorial investigation revealed that the authors did not obtain a proper license for its use. The journal’s retraction notice emphasized that one of the core submission conditions is that research should not violate intellectual property rights, including the proper licensing of any software used.
This incident highlights a growing concern in academic publishing: the necessity for proper copyright compliance. Alongside issues like plagiarism and ethical violations, the unauthorized use of software can now lead to retraction. Journals and publishers are increasingly vigilant about intellectual property rights, and the consequences for noncompliance can be severe. Researchers need to be mindful of the licenses associated with any software or tools they use to produce their work, whether that involves proprietary programs, generative AI, or images created with software tools like BioRender.
The case also underscores the ongoing tension between copyright law and the academic world. While researchers often argue for broader access to academic work, publishers continue to protect their content behind paywalls, sometimes making it difficult for researchers to freely share their findings. In some cases, this conflict has led to legal and ethical debates about copyright reform, particularly regarding the rights of researchers to distribute their own work. Some have even called for a secondary publishing right to allow researchers more control over their work, without needing permission from publishers.
As the academic landscape continues to evolve, it is essential for researchers to take responsibility for the tools and resources they use. The integrity of research is built not only on accurate findings and sound methodology but also on respect for copyright and intellectual property. Ensuring proper licensing can help avoid retractions and maintain the trust and credibility of academic work.
Click here for the Japanese version.